Edgartown Conservation Commission Meeting Agenda

Wednesday January 14 2026 4:30 p.m. 

Second Floor, Edgartown Town Hall 70 Main St, Edgartown, MA 02539

MEETING MATERIALS

4:30 RDA 

Applicant: Michael Bronner

Representative: Koen

Location: 61 Butlers Cove Rd (AP 44-46)

Project: Installation of a 600 sq ft above ground pool on an existing stone patio.  

4:35 NOI SE20-1816

Applicant: Reilly

Representative: Casey Decker (MVED)

Location: 9 & 13 Pierce Lane (AP 20D-78 & 79)

Project: Seeking permission to raise the grade on site to match 9 Pierce Lane, install a drainage system around a historic structure, demolish newer additions of said structure, lift the structure and construct a full basement beneath. Proposed plans also include a rear porch roof and patio with new landscaping and a new driveway. Also seeking permission to remove an existing retaining wall on 9 Pierce Lane and install a new retaining wall that encompasses both 9 & 13 Pierce Lane.

4:40 NOI SE20-1817

Applicant: MV Land Bank

Representative: Harrison Kisiel

Location: 8 Mindoro Lane & 31 Llewellyn Way (AP 28-5.22 & 5.243)

Project: Proposing 1,523ft. of new trail. All but 300’is in Bordering Vegetated Wetland. The trail will be cut in using hand tools at 8ft. wide and a raised boardwalk with light-penetrating decking will be constructed through its entirety. After construction the vegetation will be maintained at a 6ft. width. Additionally, invasive removal and maintenance along Sweetened Water Pond (235 ft) is proposed.  

4:45 NOI SE20-1798 (amended OOC request)

Applicant: Vineyard Vibes

Representative: Reid Silva (VLSE)

Location: 9 Lenssen Way (AP 13-22)

Project: Request for an amended Order of Conditions to adjust approved location of ADU/ guest house.

4:50 NOI LOCAL

Applicant: O’Brien/ Walsh

Representative: Reid Silva (VLSE)

Location: 56 Green Pasture Rd (AP 35-20.17)

Project: Seeking permission to remove an existing dwelling and garage with detached

bedroom. Proposing to construct and maintain a new main dwelling, detached garage with guest house above and ADU within the local 100’ buffer zone to a FEMA flood

zone.

4:55 NOI SE20-1821

Applicant: Chappy Back Nine LLC

Representative: Reid Silva (VLSE)

Location: 36 North NEck Rd (AP 18-28.3)

Project: Seeking permission to remove an existing Golf Club House, construct and maintain a new Club House, install a septic tank and pump chamber, and associated site work and landscaping within a FEMA Flood Zone AE (EL 12). 

5:00 NOI LOCAL

Applicant: Kumpitch

Representative: Reid Silva (VLSE)

Location: 52 Beach Rd Av (AP 47-57)

Project: Seeking permission to construct and maintain an addition to an existing dwelling

located within the buffer zones to a bordering vegetated wetland and a coastal bank. All work is located within the 200’ local buffer zone but outside of 100’ WPA buffer zone.

5:05 NOI SE20-1819

Applicant: Brush

Representative: Reid Silva (VLSE)

Location: 40 Green Hollow Rd (AP 29-132)

Project: Seeking permission to perform maintenance dredging of ±95 Cubic Yards adjacent to an existing private pier. Dredging was performed in the area under a previously approved dredge permit issued on March 24, 2015 (SE20-1398) and has since expired. The dredging will be done by mechanical excavator, placed on a barge and removed from the site. The spoils will be used as beach nourishment offsite.

Continued Hearings:

SE20-1815 Town of Edgartown - Comprehensive Dredge Permit, continue to 1/28/25

SE20-1778 23 Kelley St LLC - continued from 11/5/25, continue to 1/28/25

Administrative/Discussion Items:

• Enforcement Orders - Kumpitch, Monahan

• OOCs to be signed

  • SE20-1813 - Guerrera pool - approval

  • SE20-1814 - Monahan trees - denial

• CoC requests

  • 177 Katama Rd (Robb Moriarty) 

• Monahan OOC extension request

• Minutes: 12/3/25, 12/17/25

• Items not reasonably anticipated

WEBINAR INFO:

Webinar attendees will be able to observe but not participate.

Participation must be in-person or via correspondence received prior to the meeting.

Join Webinar: https://us02web.zoom.us/j/89386766445