Edgartown Conservation Commission Meeting Agenda

Wednesday June 10, 2026 4:30 p.m. 

Join Zoom Meeting https://us02web.zoom.us/j/83234440043

Meeting ID: 832 3444 0043 

Meeting Materials

4:30 PM RDA

Applicant: Denise Mulica

Representative: Shearwater Construction

Location: 15 Garden Cove Road (AP Map 53-8.2)

Project: The applicant is seeking a determination regarding the expansion of a garage footprint to accommodate an ADU. The expansion is 11 linear feet and within the buffer of a great pond and within the FEMA flood zone.

4:35 PM RDA

Applicant: Drew & Kimberly Conway

Representative: SBH, Inc.

Location: 71 North Water Street (AP Map 20D-292.1)

Project: The applicant is seeking a determination regarding a proposed garage expansion and brick patio and relocation of a brick parking area within a FEMA flood zone.

4:40 PM RDA

Applicant: Oyster Oaks LLC

Representative: SBH, Inc.

Location: 18 Oyster Watcha Road (AP Map 40-1.11)

Project: The applicant is seeking a determination regarding the development of a currently vacant property. The plans include a dwelling, ADU, pool, gym, driveway, parking, septic system, landscaping and view channels.

4:45 PM NOI SE20-1842

Applicant: Sara Wells, Tr of The Katama 2 Nominee Trust 

Representative: Casey Decker, MV Engineering & Design

Location: 9 Green Hollow Way (AP Map 29-130.1)

Project: The applicant is seeking permission to remove existing wood stairs to a pier and construct a new set of stairs and a 10’x20’ viewing platform on a coastal bank. 

Continued Hearings:

NOI SE20-1840

Applicant: John Reilly

Representative: Casey Decker, MV Engineering & Design

Location: 9 & 13 Pierce Lane (AP Map 20D Lots 78 & 79)

Project: The applicant is seeking permission to build a new retaining wall (removing an existing one), add fill on 13 Pierce Ln to raise the grade, renovate the existing dwelling on 13 Pierce Ln, and various landscaping elements.

Administrative/Discussion Items

• Waldron update (if any)

• OOCs/ CoCs to be signed

  • SE20-1835 - OPR 99 Homestead LLC - demo/rebuild, etc

  • SE20-1836 - Pocha Plover LLC - elevated boardwalk

  • SE20-1837 - Wannamaker - demo/ rebuild

  • SE20-1838 - 30 Crackatuxet - elevated boardwalk

  • SE20-1839 - D’Agostino - mowing/ veg management

  • SE20-1841 - Kumpitch - replanting

  • CoC SE20-1672 - TTOR withdrawal per SOCs

• Minutes 

• Items not reasonably anticipated